Which is better for a tall person?

The Fair Isle Throw. It is 70 inches long versus 60 for the Cabin Plaid, so it covers more of the body.

The Fair Isle has a polyester microfiber face, which most people find plusher. The Cabin Plaid has a cotton flannel face, which feels crisper and less slick.

The Cabin Plaid has a cotton fill and a faux shearling and sherpa backing, so it traps heat well. The Fair Isle is lighter microfiber with polyester fill.

Is the Cabin Plaid worth choosing over the higher-rated Fair Isle?

Yes if you want cotton, OEKO-TEX certification and a classic plaid look. The rating gap is small, 4.7 versus 4.8.

Can both go in the washing machine?

Yes. Both are machine washable per their care instructions.

Eddie Bauer Cabin Plaid Throw vs Eddie Bauer Fair Isle Throw

Buy the Cabin Plaid Throw if you want a cotton-faced, flannel-and-sherpa throw with a classic plaid look and OEKO-TEX certification. Buy the Fair Isle Throw if you want more length and a lighter, plush microfiber feel for the couch. The Fair Isle is 70 inches long versus 60 for the Cabin Plaid, and it carries the higher rating, 4.8 from 4,300 ratings versus 4.7 from 2,800.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.