Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Eddie Bauer. Its cotton face and lightweight fill are breathable, while the Tommy Hilfiger is built for extra warmth with a polyester microfiber face.

Which set gives you more pieces?

The Tommy Hilfiger, with 3 pieces. The Eddie Bauer set has 2: the quilt and shams.

Both are machine washable, but the Eddie Bauer's cotton construction and 801 ratings give more evidence of durability. The Tommy Hilfiger has only 11 ratings.

Is the Tommy Hilfiger worth the extra?

Only if you want extra warmth or a King size. No current price was given for it, so check store prices against the Eddie Bauer's recent $71.22 to $80.04 range.

Can I use either quilt alone without a duvet?

Yes. Both are reversible quilts meant to be used alone as a bed cover or layered over sheets.

Only the Tommy Hilfiger. The Eddie Bauer set is offered in Twin and Full/Queen.

Eddie Bauer Quilt Set vs Tommy Hilfiger Classic Comfort Quilt Set

Buy the Eddie Bauer Quilt Set for breathable all-season cotton and a proven track record: 4.7 out of 5 from 801 ratings. Buy the Tommy Hilfiger Classic Comfort Quilt Set if you want a warmer, plush microfiber quilt for a dorm or first apartment. The Eddie Bauer has been selling between $71.22 and $80.04 in early November 2026; no current price was given for the Tommy Hilfiger, so compare store prices before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.