Empire Gateway 1700 Wood Stove vs Vermont Castings Defiant Wood Stove
Buy the Vermont Castings Defiant if you heat a large, open space and want the cleaner, more efficient burn. Buy the Empire Gateway 1700 if you want a simpler, smaller stove with a higher peak output and a lower upfront outlay. The Defiant is the better-built flagship: cast iron, top-loading, catalytic, 1.3 g/hr emissions and 78% HHV efficiency, and owners rate it 4.5 out of 5. The Gateway is a plain steel plate stove with a one-lever control and an ash pan, easier to run but less refined.
- Choose the Empire Gateway 1700 if you have a small to medium room, want one-lever simplicity and a no-mess ash pan, and need a higher peak output in a compact 24-inch footprint.
- Choose the Vermont Castings Defiant if you are heating a large area, want the cleanest burn and longest burn times, and value cast-iron build and top-loading convenience.
Prices
- Empire Gateway 1700 Wood Stove: $1,999.00 at Flatirons Fire (checked today)
- Vermont Castings Defiant Wood Stove: $4,669.00 at Royal Fire Pits (checked today)
- Difference: the Empire Gateway 1700 Wood Stove is $2,670.00 cheaper than the Vermont Castings Defiant Wood Stove today

