Which is cheaper per battery?

AmazonBasics. At $15.29 for 48 as of November 6, 2026, it is about 32 cents a battery. Energizer MAX runs about 63 cents each at its $10.01 low and $1.41 each at its $22.48 high.

Which lasts longer in a flashlight?

Energizer MAX is the safer pick for high-drain devices like flashlights. AmazonBasics does not publish capacity or discharge figures, so there is no spec to compare directly.

Is Energizer MAX worth the extra?

Only near its low price. At $10.01 for 16 it is a reasonable buy for demanding devices. At $22.48 it costs more than four times as much per battery as the AmazonBasics pack.

Can I store these for years?

AmazonBasics states a 10-year shelf life. Energizer does not state a shelf life for MAX in the listing, so store both in a dry place and check dates on the pack.

Are either rechargeable?

No. Both are disposable alkaline AA batteries at 1.5 V. For rechargeables you need a different product.

Which is better for a household with kids' toys?

AmazonBasics, for volume and price. The 48-pack covers many toys at about 32 cents a battery, and Energizer MAX is the pick only if you find it near $10.

Energizer MAX AA Batteries (16 Pack) vs AmazonBasics AA Alkaline Batteries

Buy the AmazonBasics 48-pack if you want the lowest cost per battery for toys, remotes and other low-drain devices. Buy Energizer MAX if you need a name brand with a long track record in demanding devices like flashlights and motorized toys. The AmazonBasics 48-pack is $15.29 at Amazon as of November 6, 2026, about 32 cents a battery. Energizer MAX 16-pack prices have swung from $10.01 on November 3, 2026 to $22.48 on November 5, 2026, so cost per battery depends heavily on when you buy.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.