Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Grabie Erasable Gel Pens vs Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable

Buy the Grabie set if you want color and variety: 36 erasable gel colors in four palettes, a 0.7mm tip, and a built-in eraser on every pen. Buy the Paper Mate Erasermate if you want one dependable black pen for everyday writing. The Grabie writes smoother and looks better in journals, but its gel ink is heat-sensitive and some pens stop writing until they are chilled. The Erasermate is a tougher oil-based ballpoint with a rubber grip and a pocket clip, but it comes only in black, in a 12-pack, and its 1mm line is broad. Grabie owners rate it 4.8 out of 5 and praise the ink flow and colors; Erasermate owners value the grip and the fact that it erases cleanly.

  • Choose the Grabie if you take color-coded notes, bullet journal, or color, and want an eraser on every pen.
  • Choose the Paper Mate Erasermate if you mainly write in black and want a sturdy retractable pen with a rubber grip.

Prices

  • Grabie Erasable Gel Pens: $17.99 at Findlay Rowe Designs (checked today)
  • Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable: $11.47 at Amazon (checked today)
  • Difference: the Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable is $6.52 cheaper than the Grabie Erasable Gel Pens today
Grabie
Erasable Gel Pens by Grabie

Grabie Erasable Gel Pens

Erasable Gel Pens by Grabie

4.8(123 ratings)
$17.99at Findlay Rowe DesignsChecked 34 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Findlay Rowe Designs
Pros
  • 36 colors in four palettes, from classics to pastels
  • Smooth 0.7mm gel ink that does not skip
  • Eraser on every pen for quick fixes
  • Twist-to-open design means no lost caps
  • Non-toxic ink, fine for students
Cons
  • Gel ink can fail after heat exposure until frozen
  • No rubber grip for long writing sessions
  • Not refillable
  • Plastic barrels feel light
Paper Mate
Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable

Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable

$11.47at AmazonChecked 34 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Reliable oil-based ink that resists heat
  • Rubberized grip for long writing
  • Pocket clip stays put
  • Erases cleanly
  • Airplane-safe ink
Cons
  • Black only, no color options
  • 1mm tip gives a broad line
  • Sold in a 12-pack, more pens than some need
  • Not refillable

What separates them

Grabie Erasable Gel PensPaper Mate Erasermate Retractable
Ink typeWater-based gel, smooth and vividOil-based ballpoint, firmer and slower to lay down
Colors in the pack36 colors across four palettesBlack only
Tip size0.7mm medium1mm medium, a broader line
EraserBuilt into each penEraser tip on each pen
Grip and clipTwist-to-open body, no cap to lose, no rubber gripRubberized grip and pocket clip
Heat toleranceGel ink can stop writing after heat exposure until chilledOil-based ink holds up in heat and is airplane-safe
RefillableNot refillableNot refillable
Best useJournaling, study notes, coloring, doodlingEveryday writing and forms

Price history

$39.99$3.52
Nov 3Nov 10
  • Grabie Erasable Gel Pens: lowest $12.74 on Nov 10 at The Container Store.
  • Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable: lowest $3.52 on Nov 3 at Advantage Writing Supplies; $10.51 on Nov 10.

Prices at every store

Grabie Erasable Gel Pens

  • Findlay Rowe DesignsNew

    In stock

    $17.99Free shippingChecked 34 min ago
    Visit Findlay Rowe Designs
  • EtsyNew

    In stockSold by Seller

    $28.99+ $7.15 shippingChecked 34 min ago
    Visit Etsy
  • TargetNew

    Availability unknown

    $15.99+ $5.99 shippingChecked 34 min ago
    Visit Target
  • Books A MillionNew

    Availability unknown

    $15.99+ $7.00 shippingChecked 34 min ago
    Visit Books A Million

Also available at

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
  • UnderYoursCheck price at UnderYours
  • Paper + MoreCheck price at Paper + More
All 5 stores and price history →

Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable

  • eBayNew

    In stockSold by selectsky

    $16.29Free shippingChecked 34 min ago
    Visit eBay
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $11.47Checked 34 min ago
    Visit Amazon
  • watsinternational.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $14.99Checked Nov 3
    Visit watsinternational.com
  • spsindustrial.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $18.04+ $10.00 shippingChecked 10 h ago
    Visit spsindustrial.com

Also available at

  • OnTimeSupplies.comCheck price at OnTimeSupplies.com
  • Advantage Writing SuppliesCheck price at Advantage Writing Supplies
  • Best BuyCheck price at Best Buy

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 4 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecGrabie Erasable Gel PensPaper Mate Erasermate Retractable
MaterialPlasticPlastic
TypePenPen
Tip StyleMedium pointMedium point
Ink TypeGelOil Based
Ink HighlightsNon-toxic, Erasable, Gel InkErasable
Age RangeAll usersAdult
Typical UsersStudents, CreativesStudents
Packaging HighlightsSetPack
Tip size0.7mm medium tip—
Pack size36—
Ink colors36 Colors—
Eraserbuilt-in eraser—
Show all 34 specsShow fewer specs
SpecGrabie Erasable Gel PensPaper Mate Erasermate Retractable
Ink safetyNon-toxic—
Ink baseWater—
Item weight102 Grams—
Item dimensions6.3 x 0.51 x 3.54 inches—
Ink color—Black
Barrel color—Black
Point size—1 mm
Pen point—Medium
Packaging—12
Erasable—Yes

What reviewers say

Grabie Erasable Gel Pens

  • 4.8 / 5123 ratings

Buyers rate the set highly and mostly praise smooth, consistent ink flow and the wide color range. Erasability and the capless twist design come up as practical wins for journaling and note-taking.

What people mention
  • Ink flowPraisedBuyers say the gel ink flows smoothly and consistently without skipping.
  • Color rangePraisedOwners like the 36 colors split into four palettes.
  • ErasabilityMixedErasers work for corrections, but some note smearing or incomplete erasing.
  • Tip sizeMixedThe 0.7mm medium point suits writing and coloring but is coarse for fine detail.

Questions and answers

Which is better for bullet journaling?
The Grabie. Its 36 colors and 0.7mm gel tip suit headers, color coding, and doodles, and each pen has its own eraser. The Erasermate gives you only black and a broader 1mm line.
Which lasts longer?
The Erasermate's oil-based ink holds up better over time and in heat. Grabie gel pens can stop writing after heat exposure until you chill them, though most recover.
Is the Grabie worth stepping up to over the Erasermate?
Yes if color and smooth gel writing matter to you. If you just need a black pen for forms and quick notes, the Erasermate is the simpler, tougher choice.
Does the Paper Mate Erasermate erase as well as the Grabie?
Both erase cleanly on paper. The Erasermate's oil-based ink erases reliably, and the Grabie's gel eraser works well too, though heavy gel layers can smear before they set.
Which is better for left-handed writers?
The Erasermate. Its oil-based ink dries faster and smears less under a moving hand. Grabie gel ink stays wet longer, so a lefty may drag it.
Can I use either on exams or official forms?
Check the rules first. Erasable inks are often banned on exams and legal documents, so bring a standard pen as backup for either.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Pilot FriXion Clicker vs Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable
  • Uni-ball R:E 0.5mm vs Paper Mate Erasermate Retractable
  • Erasable Gel Pens by Grabie vs Pilot FriXion Clicker
  • Erasable Gel Pens by Grabie vs Uni-ball R:E 0.5mm

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best erasable pens
Grip type—Rubberized
Pocket clip—Yes
Refillable—No
Ink dry time—24 hours
Subtype—Ballpoint Pen
Point Type—Ballpoint, Medium
Size—Medium
Weight—0.223
Body Material—Plastic
Body Shape—Ergonomic
Smear Proof—Yes
Design Highlights—Clip