Which sofa has better leather?

The Essex uses full-grain pure-aniline Italian-tanned leather all over. The Bella uses top-grain leather only on seats and arms, with split-grain on the sides and back. The Essex leather is the higher grade but scuffs and patinas more readily.

Which is better for a family room?

The Bella's removable zip-cover seat cushions and lower price make it easier to live with. The Essex's aniline leather shows scuffs and stains, which is charming but less forgiving with kids and pets.

Is the Essex worth about $215 more?

At $1,798.40 versus $1,583.28, the Essex buys full-grain leather, a feather-down topper and a 750 lb rating. If you want a patina finish and a wider seat, yes. If you want the lowest price, the Bella wins.

Both use kiln-dried or corner-blocked wood frames and no-sag or webbing support. The Essex's full-grain leather is more durable in thickness, but its non-reversible cushions and soft aniline finish need more care. The Bella's coil-and-foam seat holds shape well.

Which fits a smaller room?

The Bella is 84 in wide and 37 in deep; the Essex is 89 in wide and 32.28 in deep. The Bella is shorter but sticks out almost 5 in more from the wall. Measure both ways before choosing.

Do either come in other sizes?

The Bella collection includes a sofa, loveseat, chair and a separate sectional. The Essex is listed as a single 89-inch sofa.

Essex 89" Leather Sofa vs Bella Leather Sofa Collection

The Essex is the better sofa for most people who want a large, plush leather centerpiece: full-grain pure-aniline Italian leather, feather-down toppers and a 750 lb capacity in an 89-inch frame. The Bella is the value pick at $1,583.28 at Home Depot as of November 7, 2026, with a tighter 84-inch footprint and a mixed top-grain/split-grain build. The Essex's lowest recent price was $1,798.40 on October 31, 2026, so the Bella saves roughly $215 at current best prices.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.