Which is better for wearing to work?

The Everlane Modern Loafer. Its leather upper, tapered toe and stacked heel read as polished, and the cushioned insole suits long days. The clog is casual and better kept for home or errands.

The loafer. Leather and a rubber outsole take resoling and routine care well. Felted wool clogs wear faster at the toe and can only be professionally cleaned.

Is the clog good if I have high arches?

Probably not. Owners with high arches report it isn't the most comfortable, and arch support is limited. The loafer's padded insole is the safer pick for arch-sensitive feet.

Can I wear the clog outside?

Yes. Owners wear it around town and praise the sole height and weight. It is a casual shoe, so it pairs with denim and dresses rather than tailoring.

Is the loafer worth stepping up to over the clog?

If you need one shoe for work and travel, yes. The loafer covers more outfits and needs less specialist care. If you mainly want warmth and easy slip-on, the clog does that better.

Do the clogs fit wide feet?

Owners say they fit true to size, including wide toe beds. Thick socks can make them feel tight, so size with the socks you plan to wear.

Everlane The Modern Loafer vs Everlane Wool Clog

These are different shoes for different jobs. The Everlane Modern Loafer is a polished leather flat with a foam-cushioned insole and rubber outsole, built for workwear and travel; owners rate it highly and call it comfortable out of the box. The Wool Clog is a casual, molded slip-on with a felted wool upper and suede lining, praised for around-the-house comfort but dinged for weak arch support and specialist cleaning. Buy the loafer for a versatile, dressed-up staple; buy the clog for warmth and easy slip-on wear.

Choose the Everlane Modern Loafer if you want one black leather shoe that works with trousers, denim and dresses and holds up to daily wear.
Choose the Wool Clog if you want a warm, casual slip-on for the house and quick errands and don't need arch support.

Prices

Everlane The Modern Loafer: $27.00 at The Family Consignment Store (checked today)
Everlane Wool Clog: $59.00 at Everlane (checked today)
Difference: the Everlane The Modern Loafer is $32.00 cheaper than the Everlane Wool Clog today

	Everlane The Modern Loafer	Everlane Wool Clog
Style	Polished leather loafer with tapered toe and stacked heel	Molded casual clog
Upper material	Napa leather	One-piece felted wool, partly recycled
Interior	Foam-cushioned insole with added padding	Suede leather lining
Arch support	Cushioned insole, no reported arch complaints	Owners say arch support is limited
Care	Leather; standard shoe care	Professional leather clean only
Warmth	Leather, unlined warmth	Felted wool holds heat
Sizing range	Single listed size only	Full size run, fits wide toe beds
Outsole	Natural rubber	Molded clog sole

Spec	Everlane The Modern Loafer	Everlane Wool Clog
Interior material	—	suede leather
Construction	—	one-piece felted wool upper
Care instructions	—	Professionally Leather Clean Only
Country of manufacture	—	Vietnam

Everlane The Modern Loafer vs Everlane Wool Clog

Prices

Everlane The Modern Loafer vs Everlane Wool Clog

Prices

Everlane Wool Clog

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Everlane The Modern Loafer

Everlane Wool Clog

Specs compared

What reviewers say

Everlane The Modern Loafer

Everlane Wool Clog

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent