Which is better for a car with start-stop?

The AUTODEPOT. It is an AGM battery built for start-stop engines, while the EverStart Plus is a flooded battery not designed for that cycle.

AGM batteries like the AUTODEPOT generally tolerate cycling and vibration better, so they tend to last longer in demanding use. The EverStart's 2-year free replacement period covers early failure.

Is the AUTODEPOT worth stepping up to?

Yes if your car has start-stop or you want more cranking margin in cold weather. If you drive a simple older car, the EverStart Plus covers the basics.

Will both fit a group 35 tray?

Yes. Both are BCI group size 35, so the footprint and terminal layout match the same vehicles. Check post orientation before installing.

Do I need a special charger for the AUTODEPOT?

Yes. AGM batteries want a charger with an AGM setting and about 14.4-15.0 V charging voltage. A standard flooded charger can overcharge it.

Which handles cold winters better?

The AUTODEPOT, with 650 CCA against 525 CCA. More cold cranking amps means easier starts in freezing temperatures.

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery vs AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery

The AUTODEPOT is the stronger pick for most shoppers: it is an AGM battery with 650 CCA against 525 CCA, and AGM handles start-stop engines and vibration better than flooded lead acid. The EverStart Plus is a simple flooded battery with a 2-year free replacement period and a large owner base rating it 4.3 out of 5. Buy the EverStart if you want a basic, proven group 35 battery for an older car without start-stop; buy the AUTODEPOT if your car has start-stop or you want more cranking power.

Choose the EverStart Plus if you drive an older car without start-stop and want a straightforward flooded battery with a 2-year free replacement period.
Choose the AUTODEPOT if your car has start-stop technology or you want the extra 125 CCA and AGM durability.

Prices

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery: $120.51 at Walmart (last seen Nov 9)
AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery: $62.99 at Shiloh Outfitters (last seen Nov 11)
Difference: the AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery is $57.52 cheaper than the EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 11)

EverStart Plus Lead Acid Automotive Battery, Group Size 35, 12 V, 525 CCA

	EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery	AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery
Battery chemistry	Flooded lead acid	AGM (absorbent glass mat)
Cold cranking amps	525 CCA	650 CCA
Reserve capacity	100 min	100 min
Start-stop support	Not designed for start-stop	Built for start-stop vehicles
Maintenance	Maintenance-free	Maintenance-free
Warranty	2-year free replacement	Not stated
Weight and size	39.2 lb, 7.2 x 6.4 x 9.04 in	About 6.89 x 9.06 x 8.82 in
Owner feedback	4.3 out of 5 from 1,138 ratings	Too few ratings to judge

Spec	EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery	AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery
Cold crank amps	525 CCA	650 CCA
Reserve capacity	100 min	100RC
Battery type	Lead Acid	AGM
Terminal type	SAE Type A	tapered terminals (Left negative (-), Right pos…
Voltage	12 V	12 Volts
personalizable	All States	—
color	Black	—
BCI group number	35	—
Post location	Top Post	—
Length	7.2 in	—
Width	6.4 in	—
Height	9.04 in	—

Spec	EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery	AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery
Weight	39.2 lb	—
Capacity	—	55Ah
BCI group size	—	Group Size 35
Dimensions	—	6.89"D x 9.06"W x 8.82"H
Charging voltage	—	14.4-15.0V
Charging current	—	0-17A
Operating temperature	—	-22°F to 158°F

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery vs AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery

Prices

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery vs AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery

Prices

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery

AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery

AUTODEPOT Group 35 AGM Car Battery

Specs compared

What reviewers say

EverStart Plus Group 35 Car Battery

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent