Pfaltzgraff Everyday White Organic Dinnerware Set vs Lenox LX Collective 12-Piece Dinnerware Set

Buy the Pfaltzgraff Everyday White Organic if you need service for eight and want four pieces per setting, including a large dinner bowl and a soup bowl. Buy the Lenox LX Collective if you want a smaller, simpler set with a matte textured finish and a bigger all-purpose bowl. The Pfaltzgraff has the edge on capacity and piece count; the Lenox has the edge on clean modern styling. Owners of the Pfaltzgraff praise its weight and sturdy feel, but some report a faint ring from the plate's underside showing through and poor follow-up from customer service. Lenox has a long porcelain reputation, though this set gives you fewer pieces per person.

• Choose the Pfaltzgraff Everyday White Organic if you feed a household of eight or want both a 40-ounce dinner bowl and a 21-ounce soup bowl in every setting.
• Choose the Lenox LX Collective if you want a compact four-person set with a matte textured look and a single deep 24-ounce bowl per setting.