Faber-Castell Polychromos Pencils, 24 vs Holbein Artists' Colored Pencils 150 Color Set

Both are oil-based artist pencils with 3.8mm cores, so the real split is range and feel. The Polychromos is the safer pick for most people: 120 colors, a hard, finely sharpenable lead that holds a point for detail work, and a long track record with a huge base of owners and reviewers. The Holbein set gives you 150 colors including metallics and a softer, creamier core that lays down color faster over large areas. Buy the Polychromos for fine detail, layering and durability; buy the Holbein for a wider palette and smoother, quicker coverage.

• Choose the Polychromos if you draw fine detail, layer many thin passes, or want a proven pencil that sharpens to a needle point and resists breaking.
• Choose the Holbein 150 set if you want the widest color range in one box, including metallics, and prefer a softer core that fills large areas quickly.