Fairfield Square Brookline Sheet Set vs Macy's Addison Park Charlotte Comforter Set

These are not substitutes: the Fairfield set is sheets and pillowcases, the Addison Park is a comforter and shams. Buy the Fairfield if you need the layer against your skin and want a deep-pocket sateen set; buy the Addison Park if you need the top layer and want two looks from one comforter. The Fairfield's 1400 thread count is a cotton/polyester blend counted with polyester yarns, and its 3.6 rating from about 2,900 owners includes complaints of pilling, fraying and roughness. The Addison Park rates 4.5 but from only 64 ratings, and owners call it soft, lightweight and washable, with some sleeping hot and mixed views on thickness.

• Choose the Fairfield Square Brookline if you need a full sheet set for a mattress up to 18 inches deep and want a smooth sateen weave with four pillowcases.
• Choose the Macy's Addison Park if you need a reversible comforter with shams and prefer a medium-warmth quilted top layer over a floral or yellow block print.