Princess Polly Fawcett Jeans vs Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean
The Fawcett is the pick for a rigid, classic straight-leg look in 100% cotton with a raw hem; the Judy Blue Peggy is the pick for comfort and a smoothing high waist. The Fawcett has no stretch, so it holds its shape and breaks in like traditional denim, but it fits unforgivingly and the raw hem can fray. The Judy Blue uses a cotton-poly-spandex blend with a tummy-control panel and a cropped ankle length, so it moves with you and flatters the midsection, though the stretch means it can bag at the knee over a long day. Reviewers rate the Fawcett well at 4.5 from 294 ratings; Judy Blue's tummy-control fit has a loyal following among shoppers who want soft denim.
- Choose the Fawcett if you want a rigid 100% cotton straight leg with a high rise and a raw hem that wears like old-school denim.
- Choose the Judy Blue Peggy if you want stretch comfort, a tummy-control high waist and a cropped ankle length.
Prices
- Princess Polly Fawcett Jeans: $37.50 at Princess Polly US (last seen Nov 12)
- Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean: $40.00 at Mattie B's (checked today)
- Difference: the Princess Polly Fawcett Jeans is $2.50 cheaper than the Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean at the latest prices (Nov 12 and Nov 18)

