Which fender fits a 2WD 1988 Toyota Pickup?

The Fender replacement. It is listed for 1984-1988 Pickup 2WD only. The Aftermarket Replacement panel is for 4WD trucks and 4Runners.

Will the Aftermarket Replacement fit my 4Runner?

Yes, if it is a 1984-1989 4Runner. It also covers 1984-1988 4WD Pickups with the 2.4 or 3.0 liter engine.

Is the cheaper fender worth it?

For a 2WD Pickup, yes. At $88.46 it saves $72.49 and adds an EDP coating. It simply does not fit 4WD trucks or 4Runners.

Do either come painted?

No. Both are bare steel with primer only. You must paint either one to match your truck.

Which has the correct holes for my trim and antenna?

The Aftermarket Replacement panel is built without antenna, molding or turn signal lamp holes. The Fender listing does not specify its cutouts, so check your truck before ordering.

Neither is galvanized or painted from the factory, so rust protection depends on prep and paint. The Fender part's EDP coating gives it a small head start.

1984-1988 Toyota Pickup Front Fender vs 84-89 Toyota 4Runner/Pickup Front Left Fender

Buy the Fender replacement if you have a 2WD 1984-1988 Toyota Pickup, and buy the Aftermarket Replacement panel if you have a 4WD truck or a 1984-1989 4Runner. The Fender part is $88.46 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026, against $160.95 at Walmart for the Aftermarket Replacement. That is a $72.49 gap, so the 4WD panel has to earn its price with the right fitment.

Today the 1984-1988 Toyota Pickup Front Fender costs $72.49 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.