StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

First-Five Grain-Free Sky Recipe vs Grain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble

Buy the First-Five Sky Recipe for an adult dog or a picky eater that does well on poultry; it leads with five named animal proteins and adds pumpkin, probiotics, taurine, l-carnitine and methionine for heart and digestion support. Buy the Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble for a puppy or a pregnant or nursing bitch, since it is explicitly a growth formula with wild-caught salmon and chicken. The First-Five has the higher rating but from far fewer reviews; the puppy food has a much larger owner base. Neither states a full guaranteed analysis here, so compare the label panels before committing.

  • Choose the First-Five Sky Recipe if you have an adult dog, want a poultry-first grain-free kibble with heart and digestion add-ins, and your dog is not sensitive to chicken or turkey.
  • Choose the Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble if you are feeding a puppy or a pregnant or nursing dog and want a growth-stage formula with salmon as a second protein.

Prices

  • First-Five Grain-Free Sky Recipe: $28.03 at Redbarn Employee (checked today)
  • Grain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble: $29.99 at Open Farm (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: the First-Five Grain-Free Sky Recipe is $1.96 cheaper than the Grain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 14)
First-Five
First-Five Kibble Grain-Free Sky Recipe

First-Five Grain-Free Sky Recipe

First-Five Kibble Grain-Free Sky Recipe

4.9(128 ratings)
$28.03at Redbarn EmployeeChecked 13 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Redbarn Employee
Pros
  • Five animal proteins lead the ingredient list
  • Pumpkin, prebiotics and probiotics for digestion
  • Guaranteed taurine, l-carnitine and methionine for heart health
  • Flaxseed and sunflower oil for skin and coat
  • Very high rating from owners of picky dogs
Cons
  • No life stage stated on the listing
  • Poultry-only proteins, so unsuitable for chicken-sensitive dogs
  • Small review base compared with the puppy food
  • Ingredients sourced globally, not all US-grown
C
Chicken & Salmon Grain-Free Puppy Kibble

Grain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble

Chicken & Salmon Grain-Free Puppy Kibble

4.8(767 ratings)
$29.99at Open FarmChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit Open Farm
Pros
  • Formulated for puppies and for pregnant or nursing dogs
  • Wild-caught salmon plus humanely raised chicken
  • Non-GMO sweet potato and pumpkin
  • Antioxidants for immune support
  • Large review base of over 700 ratings
Cons
  • No guaranteed taurine or l-carnitine stated
  • Not aimed at adult maintenance
  • Contains chicken, a common sensitivity
  • Fish smell may put off some dogs

What separates them

First-Five Grain-Free Sky RecipeGrain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble
Life stageMarketed for all breeds and all life stages, but the listing does not state a life stageFormulated specifically for growing puppies; also suitable for pregnant and nursing dogs
First ingredientsFive animal proteins first: turkey, chicken, duck meal, turkey meal, chicken mealChicken and wild-caught salmon as the lead proteins
Protein varietyPoultry only, so it is a poor fit for chicken-sensitive dogsChicken plus fish, giving a different protein to rotate to
Digestive supportPumpkin, prebiotics and probiotics named on the labelSweet potato and pumpkin as non-GMO superfoods
Heart and coat add-insGuaranteed taurine, l-carnitine and methionine; sunflower oil and flaxseed for skin and coatAntioxidants for immune support; no guaranteed taurine or l-carnitine stated
SourcingMade in the USA with globally sourced ingredientsOcean Wise recommended wild-caught salmon; humanely raised chicken
Owner feedback4.9 from 128 ratings; praised for picky eaters and ingredient quality4.8 from 767 ratings; a much larger pool of reviews

Prices at every store

First-Five Grain-Free Sky Recipe

  • Redbarn EmployeeNew

    In stock

    $28.03Checked 13 h ago
    Visit Redbarn Employee
  • AnimaliaNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $54.99Checked 13 h ago
    Visit Animalia
  • Southern AgricultureNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $62.99Checked 13 h ago
    Visit Southern Agriculture
  • PET PANTRY CANADANew

    In stockShips from Canada · duties may applyReturn policy

    $65.00Checked 13 h ago
    Visit PET PANTRY CANADA
All 10 stores and price history →

Grain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble

  • Open FarmNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $29.99Checked Nov 9
    Visit Open Farm
Prices and history →

What reviewers say

First-Five Grain-Free Sky Recipe

  • 4.9 / 5128 ratings

Owners rate it highly, with praise centered on picky dogs eating it readily and on the ingredient list. The main complaint is that it costs more than typical grain-free kibble.

What people mention
  • Picky eatersPraisedOwners say even fussy dogs finish their bowls.
  • IngredientsPraisedBuyers value the meat-first recipe and functional add-ins.
  • FlavorPraisedDogs reportedly enjoy the taste.
  • PriceCriticisedReviewers note it costs more than most grain-free kibbles.

Grain-Free Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble

  • 4.8 / 5767 ratings

Rated 4.8 out of 5 across 767 ratings, buyers are largely enthusiastic about this kibble for growing puppies. Praise centers on ingredient quality and how well puppies accept it, with only scattered notes about smell and transition issues.

What people mention
  • PalatabilityPraisedOwners say puppies eat it readily, even picky ones.
  • IngredientsPraisedBuyers value the named salmon and chicken proteins and the grain-free recipe.
  • Skin and coatPraisedSeveral owners report shinier coats and less scratching after switching.
  • TransitionMixed

Questions and answers

Which is better for a puppy?
The Chicken & Salmon Puppy Kibble. It is formulated for growth and for pregnant or nursing dogs, while the First-Five listing does not state a life stage.
Which suits a dog with chicken sensitivity?
Neither is ideal. Both lead with chicken; the puppy food adds salmon, so it offers one non-poultry protein to rotate toward, but check the full panel.
Which has more support for heart health?
The First-Five. It guarantees taurine, l-carnitine and methionine, which the puppy food does not state.
Is the First-Five worth stepping up to for an adult dog?
Yes, if your dog tolerates poultry. You get five named animal proteins plus digestion and heart add-ins, and owners rate it highly for picky eaters.
Which has more owner feedback?
The puppy food, with 767 ratings against 128 for the First-Five. Both score above 4.8, so satisfaction is similar.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • First-Five Kibble Grain-Free Sky Recipe vs Orijen Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
  • Wild-Caught Salmon Grain-Free Dog Kibble vs First-Five Kibble Grain-Free Sky Recipe
  • Chicken & Salmon Grain-Free Puppy Kibble vs Orijen Original Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
  • Wild-Caught Salmon Grain-Free Dog Kibble vs Chicken & Salmon Grain-Free Puppy Kibble
  • First-Five Kibble Grain-Free Land Recipe vs First-Five Kibble Grain-Free Sky Recipe
Some puppies had loose stools until owners slowed the switch over a week or more.