Which is better for a large backyard party?

The Flagship 1600. Its 1667 sq in holds about 60 burgers versus 18 on the Timberline, and its 40-lb hopper runs up to 40 hours per fill.

Can the Timberline sear a steak?

Only at moderate heat. It tops out at 500°F, while the Flagship 1600 reaches 700°F for direct high-heat searing.

Is the Flagship 1600 worth the price?

At $1,599 at Modern BBQ Supply as of November 3 it is $101 cheaper than the Timberline's $1,700 at Made Appliance Outlet as of November 7, with nearly double the cooking area.

Which has better smart features?

The Timberline. Its WiFIRE app adds recipe browsing and remote pellet-level monitoring; the Flagship 1600 offers WiFi control only.

Which is easier to move?

Both are freestanding and not built-in. The Flagship 1600 weighs 195 lb on wheels; the Timberline is lighter but still a stationary grill.

Which holds temperature more steadily?

The Flagship 1600 is rated within 5°F using its WiFi PID controller. Traeger claims precise control on the Timberline but publishes no figure.

Recteq Flagship 1600 Pellet Grill vs Traeger Timberline

The Flagship 1600 is the better buy for most shoppers deciding between these two. It gives you nearly double the cooking area (1667 vs 850 sq in), a wider 180–700°F range, and a 40-lb hopper, at $1,599 at Modern BBQ Supply as of November 3 versus $1,700 at Made Appliance Outlet as of November 7. The Timberline is the pick only if you want Traeger's app ecosystem, pellet sensor and Super Smoke mode and can live with 500°F max and a smaller grate.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.