StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Fossil Karli Women's Watch vs Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch

Both are Fossil three-hand quartz watches with stainless steel bracelets, so the choice comes down to shape and size. The Karli is the safer pick for most shoppers: a 32mm round case, pink mother-of-pearl dial and 5 ATM water resistance, backed by 1,300 ratings at 4.6. The Colleen suits someone who wants a small square two-tone look; its 28mm case is dressier but rated only 3 ATM, and it has far fewer ratings.

  • Choose the Karli if you want a round everyday watch with a mother-of-pearl dial and enough water resistance for handwashing and rain.
  • Choose the Colleen if you prefer a small square two-tone case and treat the watch as a dress piece rather than a daily beater.

Prices

  • Fossil Karli Women's Watch: $65.00 at eBay (last seen Nov 17)
  • Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch: $59.97 at Nordstrom Rack (checked today)
  • Difference: the Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch is $5.03 cheaper than the Fossil Karli Women's Watch at the latest prices (Nov 17 and Nov 18)
Fossil
Fossil Karli Three-Hand Women's Watch

Fossil Karli Women's Watch

Fossil Karli Three-Hand Women's Watch

4.6(1,300 ratings)
$65.00at eBayChecked Nov 17
See all prices and details
Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

Pros
  • Round 32mm case reads well on most wrists
  • Pink mother-of-pearl dial stands out from plain white faces
  • 5 ATM handles handwashing and rain
  • Large rating base with a high average
Cons
  • Silver-only finish is less versatile for gold jewelry wearers
  • Mother-of-pearl may feel too feminine for some tastes
  • Quartz means a battery swap every couple of years
Fossil
Fossil Women's Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Stainless Steel Watch

Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch

Fossil Women's Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Stainless Steel Watch

4.5(216 ratings)
$59.97at Nordstrom RackChecked 16 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Nordstrom Rack
Pros
  • Square 28mm case gives a distinct dress-watch look
  • Two-tone bracelet pairs with gold or silver jewelry
  • Removable links make sizing easy
  • Slim 14mm band suits small wrists
Cons
  • 3 ATM is not suitable for swimming or showering
  • Far fewer owner ratings than the Karli
  • Small square case can look undersized on larger wrists

What separates them

Fossil Karli Women's WatchFossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch
Case shapeRound 32mm caseSquare 28mm case
DialPink mother-of-pearlSemi-gloss white
Water resistance5 ATM, fine for splashes and handwashing3 ATM, splashes only, not for swimming or showering
Bracelet finishSilver-tone stainless steelTwo-tone gold and silver stainless steel
CrystalMineral crystalScratch-resistant mineral crystal
ClosureAdjust-O-Matic clasp, 14mm strapLink bracelet, 14mm band, links removable for fit
Owner feedback volume4.6 from about 1,300 ratings4.5 from about 216 ratings
Movement and batteryQuartz, SR626SW batteryQuartz, three-hand analog

Price history

$103.00$40.00
Oct 30Nov 19
  • Fossil Karli Women's Watch: lowest $40.00 on Nov 17 at 888Lots.com; $97.50 on Nov 19.
  • Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch: lowest $59.97 on Nov 8 at Nordstrom Rack; $103.00 on Nov 19.

Prices at every store

Fossil Karli Women's Watch

  • eBayNew

    In stockSold by reary40

    $65.00Checked Nov 17
    Visit eBay
  • uShopMall.comNew

    In stockSold by Since 2007

    $81.00Free shippingChecked 8 h ago
    Visit uShopMall.com
  • WalmartNew

    Availability unknown

    $93.00Checked Nov 6
    Visit Walmart
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $97.50Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 10 stores and price history →

Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch

  • Nordstrom RackNew

    In stock

    $59.97+ $9.95 shippingChecked 16 h ago
    Visit Nordstrom Rack
  • FossilNew

    In stock

    $97.50Free shippingChecked 16 h ago
    Visit Fossil
  • uShopMall.comNew

    Availability unknownSold by Since 2007

    $92.00Checked 16 h ago
    Visit uShopMall.com
  • Vestiaire CollectiveNew

    Availability unknown

    $93.00Checked 16 h ago
    Visit Vestiaire Collective
All 13 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecFossil Karli Women's WatchFossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch
StyleWrist—
DisplayAnalog—
Water ResistantYes—
Watch MovementQuartz—
Case Size32mm case—
Case ShapeRound Case—

What reviewers say

Fossil Karli Women's Watch

  • 4.6 / 51,300 ratings

Buyers rate the Karli highly, at 4.6 out of 5 across 1,300 ratings. Most praise its clean look and comfortable size. Complaints center on strap wear and the modest water resistance.

What people mention
  • SizePraisedOwners like the small round case as a comfortable fit for everyday wear.
  • LookPraisedReviewers say the simple dial looks clean and dressier than the price suggests.
  • StrapCriticisedSome owners report the strap wearing out with daily use.
  • Water resistanceMixedIt handles handwashing, but buyers say it is not for swimming.

Fossil Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Watch

  • 4.5 / 5216 ratings

Owners rate the Colleen highly, mostly for its two-tone look and comfortable everyday wear. Complaints are few and tend to be about the bracelet fit and the plain feature set.

What people mention
  • LookPraisedOwners say the two-tone gold and silver finish looks dressier than the price suggests.
  • ComfortPraisedMany wear it all day and call the bracelet comfortable once sized.
  • Bracelet fitMixedSeveral buyers had to remove links or take it to a jeweler to get a snug fit.
  • FeaturesCriticised

Questions and answers

Which is better for everyday wear?
The Karli. Its 5 ATM rating and round 32mm case hold up better to daily knocks and handwashing. The Colleen is fine for office wear but its 3 ATM rating limits it around water.
Which lasts longer?
Both use quartz movements and mineral crystals, so lifespan is similar. The Karli's higher water resistance gives it an edge against moisture damage over years of daily use.
Is the Colleen worth stepping up to?
Only if you specifically want a square two-tone dress watch. It costs more in most stores and offers less water resistance, so the step up is about style, not durability.
Which suits a small wrist?
The Colleen, at 28mm square with a 14mm band. The Karli's 32mm round case wears larger, though it is still modest by women's watch standards.
Can I swim with either watch?
No. The Karli's 5 ATM covers splashes and brief handwashing, and the Colleen's 3 ATM covers splashes only. Neither is rated for swimming.
Do both take standard batteries?
Yes, both are battery quartz watches. The Karli uses an SR626SW cell; the Colleen uses a comparable standard button cell, so any jeweler can replace it.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Fossil Women's Rye Watch vs Fossil Women's Colleen Three-Hand Two-Tone Stainless Steel Watch
  • Fossil Karli Three-Hand Women's Watch vs Fossil Women's Rye Watch
Some owners note the plain three-hand dial offers no date or other extras.