Brooklyn Bicycle Co. Franklin 3 vs State Bicycle Co. Core-Line Wulf

Buy the Franklin 3 Speed if you want a low-maintenance city bike with gears, fenders and an easy step-through mount. Buy the Core-Line Wulf if you want a light, simple fixed or single-speed bike for fast flat riding. The Franklin's Shimano Nexus 3 hub shifts while stopped and stays sealed from rain, and its fenders and upright fit suit commuting in street clothes. The Wulf is about 9 pounds lighter and has a flip-flop hub, but it ships needing a mechanic and has no fenders or gears. Owners of both praise build quality; Franklin owners note fender rattle and a stiff seat clamp, Wulf owners note a hard stock saddle and brake rattle.

• Choose the Franklin 3 Speed if you ride in traffic, want to shift down at stoplights, and prefer fenders and an upright position over speed.
• Choose the Core-Line Wulf if your route is flat, you want a light single-speed or fixed-gear bike, and you can handle pro assembly.