GAP Nixie Plaid Flannel Shirt vs L.L.Bean Women's Scotch Plaid Flannel Shirt

The L.L.Bean Scotch Plaid Flannel Shirt is the better-made shirt: Portuguese flannel brushed eight times per side, triple-needle stitching, corduroy trim and snap closures. The GAP Nixie Plaid is a plain 100% cotton flannel button-up with a relaxed fit and a roomier cut through the chest. Owners of L.L.Bean flannel shirts consistently rate the fabric softness and long-term durability highly; GAP flannel is a solid everyday layer but reviewers note it is lighter and less refined.

• Choose the GAP Nixie Plaid if you want a relaxed, roomy button-up that layers easily over tees and reads as casual workwear.
• Choose the L.L.Bean Scotch Plaid if you want a warmer, softer, better-finished flannel that holds up over many seasons.