Garvee 40" Tow Behind Plug Aerator vs Brinly Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 40″
The Brinly is the better aerator: 24 heat-treated steel plug spoons that pull 3-inch cores, three independently rotating tine sections, never-flat wheels and a 150 lb weight tray. The Garvee is a spike aerator, which punches holes rather than pulling cores, and its 100 lb tray is lighter. At $299.00 for the Brinly versus $106.98 for the Garvee, both as of November 1, 2026, the Brinly costs about $192 more. Buy the Brinly if core aeration matters to you; buy the Garvee if budget is the deciding factor.
Ask our shopping agent
Garvee 40" Tow Behind Plug Aerator
4.6Choose the Garvee if you want a 40-inch tow-behind aerator at the lowest price and can accept spike aeration with a 100 lb weight tray.
Pros
- Lowest price of the two by about $192
- 40-inch working width covers ground fast
- Fits ATVs and UTVs as well as lawn tractors
- Powder-coated rust-resistant steel frame
- Pneumatic tires roll smoothly over turf
Cons
- Spike design does not remove soil cores
- No stated tine count, depth or tow speed
- 100 lb weight tray is lighter than the Brinly's
What separates them
| Garvee 40" Tow Behind Plug Aerator | Brinly Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 40″ | |
|---|---|---|
| Aeration type | Steel spikes that punch holes | Plug spoons that pull 3-inch soil cores |
| Tine count and material | Steel aeration spikes, count not stated | 24 heat-treated 16-gauge steel plug spoons |
| Ground contour handling | Single rigid spike section | Three independently rotating, welded tine sections |
| Weight tray capacity | 100 lbs | 150 lbs |
| Wheels | 10-inch pneumatic tires | 10 x 3-inch never-flat wheels |
| Hitch | 1.2-inch hitch pin, fits ATV, UTV, lawn and garden tractors | Universal hitch pin for riding tractors and ZTR mowers with a rear hitch plate |
| Stated tow speed | Not stated | 5 mph maximum |
Price history
$299.00$106.98
- Garvee 40" Tow Behind Plug Aerator: lowest $106.98 on Nov 1 at Walmart; $106.98 on Nov 2.
- Brinly Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 40″: lowest $299.00 on Nov 1 at Brinly-Hardy Company; $299.00 on Nov 2.
Prices at every store
Garvee 40" Tow Behind Plug Aerator
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- Lowe'sCheck price at Lowe's
Brinly Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 40″
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Brinly-Hardy CompanyCheck price at Brinly-Hardy Company
- Home DepotCheck price at Home Depot
Specs compared
| Spec | Garvee 40" Tow Behind Plug Aerator | Brinly Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 40″ |
|---|---|---|
| Width | 40 in wide | 51 in |
| Tire Size | 10-inch pneumatic | 10 in x 3 in |
| Working Width | 40 Inches | — |
| Package Dimensions | 42.32 × 12.99 × 6.50 Inches | — |
| Material | Heavy-Duty Steel | — |
| Spike Type | Steel Aeration Spikes | — |
| Mounting Type | Tow-Behind Design | — |
| Compatibility | ATV, UTV, Lawn Tractor, Garden Tractor | — |
| Finish Type | Powder-Coated Rust-Resistant Finish | — |
| Color | Orange | — |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for compacted soil?
- The Brinly. Plug spoons pull 3-inch cores out, which opens the soil; the Garvee's spikes push holes in without removing material.
- Is the Brinly worth the extra money?
- If you aerate once or twice a year on a lawn with compaction, yes. At $299.00 versus $106.98 as of November 1, 2026, the Brinly buys core aeration, a 150 lb tray and independent tine sections.
- Which one lasts longer?
- The Brinly's heat-treated 16-gauge spoons and never-flat wheels are built for repeated towing. The Garvee's pneumatic tires and spike design have no stated durability specs.
- Can I tow either with an ATV?
- The Garvee lists ATV and UTV compatibility. The Brinly is specified for riding lawn tractors and ZTR mowers with a rear hitch plate.
- How much weight should I add?
- Use the full tray on hard ground: 150 lbs on the Brinly, 100 lbs on the Garvee. Less weight means shallower penetration.
- Which is easier to store?
- The Garvee packs to 42.32 x 12.99 x 6.50 inches. The Brinly measures 51 x 37 x 28 inches and weighs 66 lbs, so it takes more floor space.