Which is better for a garage?

The GE. It is garage ready and tested from 0°F to 110°F. The Hamilton Beach has no garage rating, so a freezing garage may keep it from holding temperature.

Is the GE worth the extra money?

If you fill a large freezer and want no defrosting, yes. At $649.95 versus $299.00 as of November 6, 2026, you pay about $351 more for double the capacity, frost-free operation and lower energy use.

Which holds more food?

The GE, at 21.3 cu ft against 10.1 cu ft. The GE also has more adjustable shelving, two baskets and two drawers.

Do I have to defrost either one?

Only the Hamilton Beach. It is manual defrost, so you empty it and thaw the ice buildup. The GE is frost free.

Which is cheaper to run?

The GE is Energy Star rated at 397 kWh/year. The Hamilton Beach has no listed Energy Star rating, so its running cost is less predictable.

Will either fit under a counter?

No. Both are freestanding uprights around 62 in tall. The GE is 28 in wide and the Hamilton Beach is 30.5 in wide.

GE Garage Ready Upright Freezer vs Hamilton Beach 10.1 cu ft Upright Freezer

Buy the GE if you need a large, frost-free freezer that can live in a garage and holds a family's worth of food. Buy the Hamilton Beach if you want the lowest entry price and a smaller footprint for a kitchen or utility room. The GE's best new price is $649.95 at B & B Appliances as of November 6, 2026, versus $299.00 at Walmart for the Hamilton Beach. That is roughly $351 more for about twice the capacity and no manual defrosting.

Today the Hamilton Beach 10.1 cu ft Upright Freezer costs $350.95 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.