Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

General Merchandise Mystery Boxes vs General Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.

Choose the American Pallet Liquidators box if you want a smaller, curated mix of 20–30 items with a stated $200–$300 retail value and no duplicates within a box. Choose the Mystery Box Wholesale 200-item box if you are reselling or stocking a store and want the lowest cost per item, about $0.75 each with free shipping. Prices for both vary by store and date; compare current listings on Deal.ai before buying.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

G
General Merchandise Mystery Boxes

General Merchandise Mystery Boxes

Choose the American Pallet Liquidators mystery box if you want a manageable 20–30 item assortment with a clear value estimate and a focus on health, beauty and electronics.

Pros
  • Clear value estimate of $200–$300+ retail per box.
  • Focused mix often heavy in health & beauty and electronics.
  • Subscription option for repeat boxes at a discount.
  • Smaller box size is easier to manage for personal use or gifts.
    • Cons
    • Higher cost per item than the 200-item box.
    • Exact contents are a surprise; no category selection.
    • Shipping cost and terms are not stated in the listing.
    G
    General Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.

    General Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.

    Choose the Mystery Box Wholesale 200-item box if you need bulk quantity at the lowest per-item cost and can handle a 14 lb box of mixed general merchandise.

    Pros
    • Very low cost per item, about $0.75 each.
    • Free standard shipping.
    • Large 200-item box suits resellers, flea marketers and dollar stores.
    • High variety: 80% to 100% of items differ within a box.
    Cons
    • Specs list 10–20 items, which conflicts with the 200-item offer.
    • No fixed retail value estimate; value depends on the mix.
    • Box is heavy (about 14 lbs) and may include categories you don't need.
    • No subscription option for repeat buyers.

    What separates them

    General Merchandise Mystery BoxesGeneral Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.
    Item count20–30 items per box200 items per box (listing also says 10–20 items in specs, but the main offer is 200)
    Cost per itemNot stated; box price divided by 20–30 itemsAbout $0.75 per item with free standard shipping
    Stated retail value$200–$300+ estimated retail value per boxUp to 95% off retail; no fixed value stated
    Category focusOften heavy in health & beauty and electronics; also home, toys, office, pet, babyBroad mix: home & garden, school & office, phone accessories, party, electronics, cosmetics, tools, media, apparel, toys
    Duplicate rateNo two boxes are the same; duplicates within a box not specified80% to 100% of items in each box are different
    ConditionBrand-new itemsNew items; damaged, used or junk removed; some may have retailer price tags
    Subscription optionWeekly and monthly subscription boxes at a discountOne-time bulk box; no subscription mentioned
    ShippingNot statedFree standard shipping

    Price history

    • General Merchandise Mystery Boxes: lowest $650.00 on Oct 31 at Blue Bird Liquidation.
    • General Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.: lowest $52.27 on Oct 31 at eBay.

    Prices at every store

    General Merchandise Mystery Boxes

    • American Pallet LiquidatorsCheck price at American Pallet Liquidators
    • Blue Bird LiquidationCheck price at Blue Bird Liquidation
    Prices and history →

    General Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.

    • Mystery Box WholesaleCheck price at Mystery Box Wholesale
    • eBayCheck price at eBay
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecGeneral Merchandise Mystery BoxesGeneral Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.
    Box size—16x16x16 inches (or larger depending on current…
    Weight—approximately 14lbs each
    Item count—10-20 items

    What reviewers say

    General Merchandise Mystery Box Assortment (200 New Premium items) Liquidation Sale with Products from Target, Amazon, Walmart, etc.

    Buyers of this seller's boxes generally report good value and mostly new, usable goods rather than junk, and many reorder. The common theme is variety: boxes are said to hold largely different items with few duplicates.

    Pros
    • Good value for the money
    • Mostly new products, not damaged or junk goods
    • 80% to 100% of items differ within a box
    • Repeat buyers come back for more
    Cons
    • Contents are random, so some boxes suit a buyer better than others
    • Category mix can include items a household has no use for

    Questions and answers

    Which is better for reselling?
    The Mystery Box Wholesale 200-item box is better for reselling because the cost per item is about $0.75 and it is aimed at flea marketers and dollar stores. The American Pallet Liquidators box is smaller and better for personal use or gifts.
    Which box has a higher retail value?
    American Pallet Liquidators states an estimated retail value of $200–$300+ per box. Mystery Box Wholesale states up to 95% off retail but does not give a fixed value, so the actual value depends on the mix.
    Are the items new?
    Both list new items. American Pallet Liquidators says brand-new items. Mystery Box Wholesale says all items are new and damaged, used or junk items are removed, though some may still have retailer price tags.
    How many items will I get?
    American Pallet Liquidators sends 20–30 items per box. Mystery Box Wholesale's main offer is 200 items, but its specs also mention 10–20 items, so confirm the count with the store before buying.
    Is one worth the extra cost?
    If you want a curated mix with a stated value and a subscription option, the American Pallet Liquidators box may be worth it. If you want the lowest cost per item and free shipping, the Mystery Box Wholesale 200-item box is the better value.

    More comparisons

    • General Merchandise Mystery Boxes vs Liquidated General Merchandise Lot

    Buying guides that pick them

    • Best liquidation pallets of general merchandise