Gesthaven 6-Piece Dining Set vs Wrenning 5-Piece Dining Table Set

Both sets are 4.7-rated and seat four, so the choice comes down to seating and style. The Gesthaven adds a bench, giving a fifth seat and a casual two-tone mango wood look; its contoured chairs and adjustable levelers help on uneven floors. The Wrenning is all chairs, with foam-cushioned upholstered seats and backs, a fretwork backrest and a lower storage shelf, in a light gray transitional finish. Owners of the Wrenning report easy, well-sorted assembly and a finish that holds up; the Gesthaven has fewer ratings but no pattern of complaints.

• Choose the Gesthaven if you want a bench for a fifth seat, a casual wood-and-blue look, and contoured wood seats that wipe clean.
• Choose the Wrenning if you want upholstered comfort for long dinners, a lower shelf for storage, and a neutral gray finish that suits transitional rooms.