Which is cheaper per square foot?

The Gibraltar panel works out to about $1.17 per sq ft at $19.98 for roughly 17 sq ft. The Garvee pack is about $1.76 per sq ft at $175.99 for about 100 sq ft.

Which is better for a small shed repair?

The Gibraltar panel. One 8 ft sheet covers a small patch or a narrow run, and you do not have to buy 20 panels.

Which is better for a carport or garage roof?

The Garvee 20-pack. It covers about 100 sq ft and ships with screws, which saves a separate fastener order.

Does the Gibraltar panel include screws?

No. The listing names only the panel, so budget for fasteners and trim separately.

Both are galvanized steel, so service life depends on coating care and climate. Gibraltar states 31-gauge steel and a 3/12 minimum pitch; Garvee does not publish a gauge, so its thickness is harder to verify.

Is the Garvee pack worth the extra money?

Yes if you need the full 100 sq ft and the included screws. For a single small repair, the $19.98 Gibraltar panel is the cheaper way in.

Gibraltar Building Products Corrugated Steel Roof Panel vs Garvee Metal Roofing Panels 20 Pcs, Heavy Duty Galvanized Steel Roof Sheets 73.2x16.77inch, Waterproof, Rust Resistant, Easy Install, Includes Screws for Carports, Garages, Warehouses, Pergolas, Brown

Buy the Gibraltar panel if you need a single 8 ft sheet to patch or finish a small roof or siding job at a low entry price. Buy the Garvee 20-pack if you are covering roughly 100 sq ft and want screws included in one order. The Gibraltar panel is $19.98 at The Home Depot as of November 4, 2026, and the Garvee 20-pack is $175.99 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026.

Today the Gibraltar Building Products Corrugated Steel Roof Panel costs $156.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent