Which board is better for a home lab NAS?

The ASUS P12R-I, if you have a Xeon E-2300 CPU, because its 6 SATA ports and AST2600 BMC suit multi-drive storage. The Gigabyte has only 4 SATA ports but adds a Gen5 M.2 for fast cache.

Can I use a Ryzen CPU in the ASUS P12R-I?

No. The P12R-I is LGA 1200 and supports only Intel Xeon E-2300-series processors. Ryzen and EPYC 4004 chips need the AM5 socket on the Gigabyte MC13-LE2.

Which supports more memory?

The Gigabyte MC13-LE2 supports up to 128 GB of DDR5 ECC UDIMM across 4 slots. The ASUS P12R-I tops out at 64 GB of DDR4 across 2 slots.

Do both have remote management?

The ASUS P12R-I has an ASPEED AST2600 BMC with 64 MB dedicated video for out-of-band management. The Gigabyte lists a dedicated 10/100/1000 management LAN, so check its BMC details before relying on it.

Which is easier to fit in a small case?

The ASUS P12R-I at 6.7 x 6.7 inches fits Mini-ITX cases. The Gigabyte is Micro ATX at 244 x 244 mm and needs a larger chassis.

Is the Gigabyte worth it over the ASUS?

Only if you are buying a new AM5 CPU. It gives DDR5, 128 GB capacity and PCIe Gen5, but no prices were provided, so check current store prices on Deal.ai.

Gigabyte MC13-LE2 Server Motherboard vs ASUS P12R-I Server Motherboard

These are server boards for different platforms, not interchangeable picks. Buy the Gigabyte MC13-LE2 if you are building on AM5 with a Ryzen or EPYC 4004 CPU and want DDR5, PCIe Gen5 storage and 128 GB of memory. Buy the ASUS P12R-I only if you already have an Intel Xeon E-2300 CPU and need a tiny Mini-ITX board with 6 SATA ports and BMC management. No prices were provided for either board, so compare live store prices on Deal.ai before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.