Good American Vintage Straight Ankle Jeans vs Eddie Bauer Women's Iconic Perfect Straight Jean

The Good American Vintage Straight Ankle is the sharper, more fashion-forward pick: a cropped 27.5-inch inseam, button fly, yellow wash and distressed details, cut for a size-14 shopper who wants a statement pair. The Eddie Bauer Iconic Perfect Straight is the more versatile, lower-stretch everyday jean with classic 5-pocket styling and a full-length straight leg. Build quality is solid on both; Good American's 99% cotton with 1% elastane gives a bit more give, while Eddie Bauer's low-stretch denim is made to hold its shape through long wear. Owners of both brands generally praise fit consistency, though the cropped ankle length and rips on the Good American limit it to casual wear.

• Choose the Good American Vintage Straight Ankle if you want a cropped, button-fly straight jean with stretch and a distressed, statement look for casual outfits.
• Choose the Eddie Bauer Iconic Perfect Straight if you want a full-length, low-stretch straight jean with classic 5-pocket styling that works for everyday wear and dressing up.