Goodyear Reliant All-Season Tire vs Continental ContiProContact 235/55R17 99H

The Goodyear Reliant is the safer buy for most shoppers: it is a Walmart-exclusive all-season with a 65,000-mile warranty, Aquatred grooves for wet traction, and a huge owner base at 4.5 stars. The Continental ContiProContact is a premium touring tire with a silica compound, low rolling resistance and a 400 AA A UTQG rating, but it has only 10 ratings here and a shorter 60,000-mile warranty. Pick the Goodyear for value and proven wet grip; pick the Continental if you want a quieter, more fuel-efficient touring ride and trust the brand's premium reputation.

• Choose the Goodyear Reliant if you want a proven all-season with strong wet braking, a longer treadwear warranty and a large record of owner ratings.
• Choose the Continental ContiProContact if you want a premium touring tire with low rolling resistance, a quiet ride and a solid UTQG rating.