Which is better for a chocolate lover?

The Bonnie and Pop tin. Every one of its 15 pieces is chocolate, and it costs $38.99 versus $79.95 for the Encore.

Which is better for an office or family?

The Encore. At 4 lb with popcorn, cashews and savory mix, it covers more tastes than the 2.3 lb all-chocolate tin.

Is the Encore worth double the price?

Only if you want the larger size and the savory items. For chocolate alone, the tin delivers more chocolate per dollar.

Which arrives better in warm weather?

The tin ships with ice packs from May through October. The Encore offers overnight and 2-day shipping on select days, which helps but is not automatic.

Does either come gift-ready?

Both do. The tin arrives in a keepsake tin with no wrapping needed, and the Encore comes in a basket with presentation buyers praise.

Which has a better track record?

The Encore shows 4.8 out of 5 from 33 ratings, though some buyers report late delivery. The tin has no rating shown, so there is less to go on.

Gourmet Chocolate Gift Basket in Keepsake Tin vs Encore Gourmet Gift Basket

Buy the Bonnie and Pop tin for a pure chocolate gift at about half the price: $38.99 at Bonnie and Pop as of November 6, 2026, versus $79.95 at GiftTree.com for the Encore. Choose the Encore if you want a larger, mixed sweet-and-savory basket with branded items like Lindor truffles and a 73% dark chocolate bar. The tin is the better value per dollar; the Encore is the bigger, more varied gift.

Today the Gourmet Chocolate Gift Basket in Keepsake Tin costs $40.96 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.