Which is better for a puppy?

The Honest Kitchen clusters. They are labeled all life stages, while Blue Buffalo Freedom is adult only.

Which is better for an older small dog?

Blue Buffalo Freedom adds glucosamine for joints, but its kibble is standard adult food. The Honest Kitchen clusters are all-life-stage but hard, so soften them for senior dogs.

Is the Honest Kitchen food worth the extra $6.50?

If human-grade ingredients and all-life-stage feeding matter to you, yes. If you just want grain-free chicken kibble for an adult dog, Blue Buffalo does the job for less.

Which has more protein?

The Honest Kitchen lists 26.5% minimum protein and 15.5% minimum fat. Blue Buffalo does not publish those figures in its listing, so a direct comparison is not possible.

Can I use the Honest Kitchen clusters as treats?

Yes. The maker says to serve them as a main meal, pair with a topper or use them as training treats.

Which lasts longer per bag?

Both are 4 lb bags. The Honest Kitchen bag holds about 16 cups at 400 kcal per cup; Blue Buffalo does not state cups or calories, so check the bag label.

Honest Kitchen Whole Food Clusters Small Breed vs Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Small Breed

Buy the Honest Kitchen clusters if you want human-grade ingredients, all-life-stage feeding and a food that doubles as training treats. Buy Blue Buffalo Freedom if you want the lower price and an adult-only small-breed formula with glucosamine for joints. On November 7, 2026, Blue Buffalo is $21.98 at Walmart and Honest Kitchen is $28.49 at Amazon, so Blue Buffalo costs about $6.50 less per 4 lb bag.

Today the Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Small Breed costs $6.51 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.