Great Value Purified Drinking Water 40-Pack vs Niagara Purified Drinking Water 24-Pack
Both are plain purified water in 16.9 fl oz PET bottles with twist-off caps, so taste and build are close to identical. The real split is pack size: Great Value gives you 40 bottles, Niagara gives you 24. Buy Great Value for a household, an office or a team that goes through water fast; buy Niagara when you want a smaller pack that fits a pantry shelf or a single trip. Owners of both report the same thing: the bottles are thin and crinkle when squeezed, and the caps seal fine.
- Choose the Great Value if you want more bottles per pack for a family, a fridge at work or a group event.
- Choose the Niagara if you want a smaller, easier-to-store pack and a brand you may already know.
Prices
- Great Value Purified Drinking Water 40-Pack: $3.15 at Water Butlers (checked today)
- Niagara Purified Drinking Water 24-Pack: $20.41 at Walmart (checked today)
- Difference: the Great Value Purified Drinking Water 40-Pack is $17.26 cheaper than the Niagara Purified Drinking Water 24-Pack today

