Dooney & Bourke Gretta Domed Satchel vs Dooney & Bourke Pebble Grain Allison Crossbody

Both are Dooney & Bourke bags with zip tops and a detachable strap, but they solve different problems. The Gretta Domed Satchel is the bigger, lighter, more organized bag: coated cotton, a 9.75-inch length, an outside zip pocket, a key hook and feet, and owners say the structure keeps it tidy. The Pebble Grain Allison Crossbody is smaller and made of leather, so it feels dressier and more durable against scuffs, but it holds less and has fewer pockets. Buy the Gretta for everyday carrying and organization; buy the Allison for a compact leather bag you can wear hands-free.

• Choose the Gretta Domed Satchel if you want a roomy, lightweight everyday bag with an outside zip pocket, a key hook and feet, and you like a coated cotton that shrugs off rain.
• Choose the Pebble Grain Allison Crossbody if you want a small leather bag with a dressier look and a detachable strap for hands-free carrying.