StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Happy Birthday Cake Charm vs Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm

The Happy Birthday Cake Charm is the fun pick: a gold-plated stainless steel cake with pastel enamel and a hinged base that opens to a hidden "HAPPY B-DAY" message. The Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip is the classic pick: solid sterling silver, 100% recycled metal, a lobster clasp and a soft pouch, with a 5-out-of-5 rating from 14 owners. Build quality favors the number charm, since sterling silver outlasts gold plating and enamel over time. Choose the cake for personality and a surprise; choose the number for a milestone birthday and metal that holds up.

  • Choose the Happy Birthday Cake Charm if you want a playful, openable charm with enamel color and a hidden message for a friend, sister or daughter who collects charms.
  • Choose the Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip if you want a specific milestone number in solid recycled sterling silver with a secure lobster clasp and a gift pouch.

Prices

  • Happy Birthday Cake Charm: $5.99 at School Crossing (last seen Nov 17)
  • Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm: $26.93 at TheCharmWorks (last seen Nov 17)
  • Difference: the Happy Birthday Cake Charm is $20.94 cheaper than the Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm at the latest prices (Nov 17)
H
Happy Birthday Cake Charm

Happy Birthday Cake Charm

5(2 ratings)
$5.99at School CrossingChecked 7 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit School Crossing
Pros
  • Hinged base reveals a hidden "HAPPY B-DAY" message
  • Pastel pink, blue and lilac enamel stands out on a stack
  • Works on a bracelet or as a necklace focal point
  • Suits birthdays any age, not just milestones
Cons
  • Gold plating and enamel can wear over time
  • Hinge is a small mechanism that needs care
  • No gift pouch included
  • Limited owner feedback so far
S
Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip on Charms

Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm

Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip on Charms

5(14 ratings)
$26.93at TheCharmWorksChecked 9 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit TheCharmWorks
Pros
  • Solid 100% recycled sterling silver
  • Lobster clasp clips on and off easily
  • Choose the exact birthday number from 13 to 60
  • Arrives in a soft drawstring pouch
  • Rated 5 out of 5 by 14 owners
Cons
  • One number per charm, so it dates to a single birthday
  • Flat 2.6cm design is less eye-catching than a 3-D piece
  • No color or enamel options

What separates them

Happy Birthday Cake CharmSterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm
MetalGold-plated stainless steel with enamelSterling silver, 100% recycled
Design3-D birthday cake with pastel enamel frostingFlat number charm with lettering
Moving partsHinged base opens to a hidden messageFixed piece, no mechanism
AttachmentSlides onto a charm bracelet or chainLobster clasp clips on and off a bracelet or purse
PersonalizationOne design, four color patternsPick your birthday number, 13 to 60
DurabilityPlating and enamel can wear with daily wearSolid silver resists wear and can be polished
Gift packagingNo pouch mentionedSoft drawstring pouch included
Owner feedbackNewer novelty piece, little owner feedback5 out of 5 from 14 ratings, praised for quality and size

Price history

  • Happy Birthday Cake Charm: lowest $20.00 on Nov 12 at Alex and Ani.

Prices at every store

Happy Birthday Cake Charm

  • School CrossingNew

    In stock

    $5.99Checked 7 h ago
    Visit School Crossing
  • Ellie B. Children's BoutiqueNew

    In stock

    $6.00Checked 7 h ago
    Visit Ellie B. Children's Boutique
  • Treehouse ToysNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $6.00Checked 7 h ago
    Visit Treehouse Toys
  • Tomfoolery Toys and BooksNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $6.99Checked 7 h ago
    Visit Tomfoolery Toys and Books
All 12 stores and price history →

Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm

  • TheCharmWorksNew

    In stockShips from the UK · duties may applyReturn policy

    $26.93Checked 9 h ago
    Visit TheCharmWorks
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecHappy Birthday Cake CharmSterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm
MaterialSilver, Sterling SilverSterling Silver
age groupAdults, All ages, Teens—
color patternGold, Pink, Blue, Purple—
jewelry materialGold-plated, Enamel, Stainless steel—
jewelry typeImitation jewelry—
target genderUnisex—
TypeCharm—
Height—2.6cm
Width—1.1cm
Depth—0.2cm
Model number—CHZ-216

What reviewers say

Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip-On Charm

  • 5 / 514 ratings

Buyers give it full marks and describe it as a lovely-quality charm with beautiful lettering.

What people mention
  • QualityPraisedBuyers describe the silver and finish as lovely quality.
  • LetteringPraisedThe style of the number lettering is called beautiful.
  • SizePraisedOwners say the charm is a nice size on a bracelet.
  • Gift packagingPraisedThe drawstring pouch is described as a lovely little gift bag.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a milestone birthday gift?
The Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip, because you pick the exact number and it comes in a pouch ready to give. The cake charm suits any birthday but does not mark a specific age.
Which lasts longer?
The sterling silver number charm. Solid silver resists wear and can be polished, while gold plating and enamel on the cake charm can dull or chip with daily wear.
Can I wear either on a necklace?
The cake charm slides onto a chain or clips to a bracelet. The number charm has a lobster clasp, so it clips onto a bracelet, a chain or a purse.
Is the cake charm worth stepping up to over a plain number charm?
If you want personality, yes. The opening base and enamel make it a talking piece. If you want a keepsake that ages well, the silver number is the safer choice.
Do they fit standard charm bracelets?
The cake charm is made for charm bracelets and necklaces. The number charm's lobster clasp fits most bracelets and bags, though check the clasp size on a very thin chain.
Which is better for a teen?
The cake charm, for its color and surprise element. The number charm works too, especially for a 13th or 16th birthday.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Happy Birthday Cake Charm vs Pandora Happy Bday Balloon Dangle Charm
  • Happy Birthday Cake Charm vs Pandora Disney Stitch Birthday Cake Charm
  • Pandora Happy Bday Balloon Dangle Charm vs Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip on Charms
  • Pandora Disney Stitch Birthday Cake Charm vs Sterling Silver Birthday Number Clip on Charms

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best birthday charms