Pandora Happy Birthday Cake Dangle Charm vs Pangama Pink Bow & Hearts Birthday Cake Charm

Both are birthday charms in 925 sterling silver that fit Pandora-style bracelets. The Pandora charm is the safer pick for a collector: it is 14k gold-plated over Pandora's own metal blend, hand-finished, and rated 4.7 from 313 ratings, so its finish and fit are proven. The Pangama Pink Bow charm is the more playful, colorful choice, with enamel icing, a pink bow and light blue crystals, but it has no rating history here and its plating and finish are not stated. Buy the Pandora for a gold-tone bracelet or a gift that must match an existing Pandora collection; buy the Pangama for a bright, whimsical look at a lower commitment.

• Choose the Pandora Happy Birthday charm if you want a gold-plated, hand-finished piece with a strong rating record that matches a Pandora Moments bracelet.
• Choose the Pangama Pink Bow charm if you want a colorful enamel cake with a pink bow and pastel hearts rather than a gold-tone metal look.