Harvest Chicken & Ancient Grains Dog Kibble vs Goodbowl Wild-Caught Salmon & Brown Rice Kibble

Both are grain-inclusive, traceable kibbles with strong owner ratings, so the choice comes down to protein and process. The Harvest Chicken & Ancient Grains is the better fit for most small and medium dogs: chicken first, no peas, potatoes or legumes, and a formula that covers puppies through seniors. The Goodbowl Wild-Caught Salmon & Brown Rice is oven-baked in small batches with salmon first, which suits dogs that do better on fish or owners who prefer a baked kibble. Note that the Goodbowl formula lists peas and fava beans and is not cleared for large-breed puppies.

• Choose the Harvest Chicken & Ancient Grains if your dog does well on chicken and you want a legume-free, potato-free kibble that works from puppy through senior years.
• Choose the Goodbowl Wild-Caught Salmon & Brown Rice if you want fish as the first ingredient and prefer a small-batch oven-baked kibble.