Hawthorne 3-Piece Wicker Swivel Conversation Set vs Martha Stewart Bedford 5-Piece Patio Dining Set

Buy the Hawthorne if you want lounge seating: two deep, high-backed swivel gliders with 6-inch cushions and a side table. Buy the Martha Stewart if you want a dining table for meals, with four stackable chairs and an umbrella hole. The Hawthorne is the more comfortable and better-built set, with a 400 lb seat rating and a triple-layer frame coating; the Martha Stewart is lighter-duty aluminum rated at 200 lbs per chair, with thin 2.5-inch cushions. Owner feedback on the Hawthorne is strong at 4.9 from over 5,800 ratings, though some report shipping delays and missing hardware. The Martha Stewart has few ratings and a lower 4.3, and its chairs are armless and firm.

• Choose the Hawthorne if you want two cushioned swivel gliders for lounging on a porch or patio, with a side table between them.
• Choose the Martha Stewart if you need a round table for eating and drinking outdoors and want chairs that stack away when not in use.