Hawthorne 9-Piece Wicker Outdoor Set vs Summit Living 8-Piece Patio Set with Fire Pit

Buy the Hawthorne if you want a deep, plush seat and a swivel chair that holds up to 400 lb. Buy the Summit Living if you want a fire pit table and a large umbrella in the same set. The Hawthorne has thicker 6-inch cushions, a taller 21-inch back and a 2-year frame and wicker warranty. The Summit Living chairs are rated to 300 lb and have a 17.5-inch seat height, and its 56-inch fire pit table and 13-foot umbrella are the main draw. Owners of the Hawthorne praise the cushion comfort and sturdy build, but some report missing pieces and sets shipped in separate boxes.

• Choose the Hawthorne if you want the plusher seat, the higher back and the stronger weight rating for everyday lounging.
• Choose the Summit Living if a fire pit table and a wide umbrella matter more to you than cushion depth.