Catrice HD Liquid Coverage Foundation vs L'Oréal Infaillible 24H Matte Cover Foundation

Both are matte, long-wear liquid foundations for oily and normal skin, and both contain niacinamide. The Catrice HD Liquid Coverage is the better pick for a natural second-skin look: it is ultra-light, waterproof, sweatproof and transferproof, and its dropper gives precise control. The L'Oréal Infaillible 24H Matte Cover is the better pick for full coverage and shine control, with SPF 25, an oil-free non-comedogenic formula and perlite to absorb shine. Reviewers rate the Catrice highly and many compare it to a high-end foundation; the L'Oréal is the sturdier choice for very oily skin and long days.

• Choose the Catrice HD Liquid Coverage if you want a lightweight, high-coverage matte that stays put through sweat and water and looks like skin.
• Choose the L'Oréal Infaillible 24H Matte Cover if you need full coverage, shine control and SPF 25 in one step for oily or acne-prone skin.