Which ring looks bigger on the hand?

The Eternate. Its heart is 1.00 ct and about 6.50 mm wide. The Beauties Jewelry NYC stone is 4.3 mm and 0.16–0.30 ct, so it reads as a small accent heart.

Is a lab-grown diamond worse than a mined one?

No. A lab-grown diamond is chemically and optically a diamond, with the same hardness. Mined stones hold resale value better; lab-grown stones cost far less per carat.

Which is better for an engagement ring?

The Eternate, for most shoppers. A 1.00 ct VS1 heart in your choice of metal is a more substantial engagement ring. The Beauties ring suits a promise ring, a gift or a stacking piece.

Does the Beauties ring last as long?

The gold will. Solid 14k gold with a 1.5 mm shank is durable, but a 1.5 mm shank is thin and should be checked for wear. The Eternate offers platinum and 18k gold, which are harder-wearing choices.

Is the Eternate worth $865.00?

Yes for a 1.00 ct E–F VS1 lab-grown heart with metal options. Compare it against other 1 ct heart solitaires before you buy; the Beauties ring has no listed price here to weigh against it.

Can I resize either ring?

Eternate lists US 2–11 and takes custom size requests. Beauties Jewelry NYC does not state sizing, so ask the store before ordering.

Heart Cut Solitaire Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring (1.00 CT) vs Heart-Shape Diamond (0.16 Ct .Tw) Solitaire Ring

Buy the Eternate 1.00 ct heart solitaire if you want a visible, colorless lab-grown center stone and a choice of metals and colors. Buy the Beauties Jewelry NYC ring if you want a small natural-diamond heart ring made in New York at a low price. The Eternate is $865.00; the Beauties Jewelry NYC ring has no price given here, so compare it on the store page before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent