Helly-Hansen Reine Parka vs J Lindeberg Alon Down Parka

The Reine is the better pick for wet, slushy winters and outdoor use. Its Helly Tech membrane and PrimaLoft Rise insulation are rated waterproof, windproof and breathable, and the synthetic fill keeps warming when damp. The Alon is the better pick for dry cold and city wear. Its 600-fill duck down is warmer for its weight, and the three-layer shell with taped seams, removable hood and magnetic placket give it a cleaner, more tailored look. Owners of down parkas like the Alon praise the warmth-to-bulk ratio but note down loses loft when soaked and needs careful washing. The Reine is heavier and bulkier but more forgiving in foul weather.

• Choose the Helly-Hansen Reine if you face rain, sleet and slush and want a hooded parka that stays warm when wet and shrugs off a downpour.
• Choose the J Lindeberg Alon if you want maximum warmth with less bulk for cold, mostly dry city days and prefer a sharper tailored silhouette.