Hermann Oak Veg-Tan Leather 4-5oz Grade B vs ELW Vegetable Tanned Tooling Leather 5/6 oz
Buy the Hermann Oak side if you want a large, consistent piece of American veg-tan for carving, tooling and dyeing, and you don't mind sorting around Grade B marks. Buy the ELW two-piece set if you want pre-cut, clean panels in a slightly heavier 5/6 oz weight for holsters, sheaths and wet molding, with less waste to trim. Hermann Oak is the better-known tanning name for tooling response and takes dye and stamps predictably; ELW's bull hide is stiffer and denser, which suits molded and structural work. Owners of both report good results, though ELW buyers note the leather cost eats into margin on resale pieces.
- Choose the Hermann Oak if you want a full single shoulder in 4–5 oz for carving, stamping and dyeing projects where you control the cut and the finish.
- Choose the ELW 2-piece set if you want clean pre-cut panels in 5/6 oz for holsters, sheaths, armor and wet-molded work.
Prices
- Hermann Oak Veg-Tan Leather 4-5oz Grade B: $330.00 at Amazon (checked today)
- ELW Vegetable Tanned Tooling Leather 5/6 oz: $39.98 at Burch HIll Tack (checked today)
- Difference: the ELW Vegetable Tanned Tooling Leather 5/6 oz is $290.02 cheaper than the Hermann Oak Veg-Tan Leather 4-5oz Grade B today

