HOKA Challenger 8 GTX vs PUMA Fast-Trac Nitro GTX

Both are waterproof neutral trail shoes with Gore-Tex liners and rubber outsoles. The Challenger 8 GTX is the more cushioned, more protective pick, with a wider fit and a rockered ride that suits long days and mixed road-to-trail use. The Fast-Trac Nitro GTX is lighter and more agile, with a dual-foam midsole and drainage ports that suit faster runs on loose gravel. Owners rate the HOKA well overall; the PUMA draws praise for fit and quality but has a smaller review base.

• Choose the HOKA Challenger 8 GTX if you want maximum cushioning, a wide fit option and a shoe that handles road miles as well as trail.
• Choose the PUMA Fast-Trac Nitro GTX if you want a lighter, quicker shoe for gravel and loose trails with drainage for wet runs.