Hoka Kaha 2 Frost GTX vs The North Face Shellista V Mid Boot

Buy the Hoka Kaha 2 Frost GTX for serious cold-weather hiking, deep snow and long days on rough ground. Buy The North Face Shellista V Mid for everyday winter wear, town use and women who want a leather boot that looks good with jeans. The Hoka has the stronger technical package: GORE-TEX, Vibram Megagrip with 5 mm lugs, 400g insulation rated to -25°F and a cushioned dual-density midsole. The Shellista V Mid is lighter, has a full-grain leather and suede upper with a fleece lining, and is built for pavement and packed snow rather than trails. Owners praise the Hoka's cushioning and grip but note its weight and bulk; the Shellista draws praise for warmth and comfort but its 200g insulation and 4.5 mm lugs suit milder winters.

• Choose the Hoka Kaha 2 Frost GTX if you hike in cold, wet or snowy conditions and want maximum warmth, waterproofing and traction underfoot.
• Choose The North Face Shellista V Mid if you want a lighter, leather winter boot for commuting, errands and casual wear in moderate cold.