Hoka Speedgoat 6 vs Brooks Caldera 8

Both are max-cushion neutral trail shoes for long days, but they suit different feet. The Speedgoat 6 has the more proven grip: a Vibram Megagrip outsole with directional lugs that holds on wet rock and loose dirt, and it comes in wide widths. The Caldera 8 has a wider, more stable platform and a slightly higher 6 mm drop that spares the calves and Achilles, and reviewers call it plush yet responsive on steep, rocky terrain. Reviewers ding the Speedgoat for running small and the Caldera for running big and for laces that come undone.

• Choose the Speedgoat 6 if you want the most reliable wet-rock and loose-dirt traction, a lower 5 mm drop, and a choice of wide widths.
• Choose the Caldera 8 if you want a wider, more stable platform, a bit more drop for tired calves, and plush protection on steep technical descents.