Holiday Time 7' Pre-Lit Shelton Pencil Tree vs Best Choice Products 6ft Pre-Lit Pencil Tree

Buy the Holiday Time Shelton if you want a tall, slim tree with LED lights that stay cool and last for years. Buy the Best Choice Products pencil tree if you want a shorter, lighter tree and don't mind incandescent bulbs. The Holiday Time has the stronger record: 4.8 from 2,813 ratings against 4.1 from 416. It also gives you an extra foot of height and 50 more lights in a footprint that is still only 19 inches wide. The Best Choice tree is simpler and lighter at 9.9 lb, but it has no written warranty and no NRTL safety listing, and its incandescent bulbs run hotter and use more power than LEDs.

• Choose the Holiday Time Shelton if you need a 7-foot tree for a narrow spot and want warm white LED lights and a large, well-rated owner base.
• Choose the Best Choice Products pencil tree if a 6-foot height suits your room and you want the lightest, easiest tree to move and store.