Homy Casa Charlton 26" Swivel Counter Stool vs Armen Living Gardenia Swivel Counter Stool

Buy the Homy Casa set if you need two matching stools for a kitchen island and want a full upholstered back in a soft fabric. Buy the Armen Living Gardenia if you want one stool with arms, a footrest and wipe-clean faux leather. The Homy Casa is the better value per seat and rates well with owners at 4.5 from 219 ratings; the Gardenia is sturdier per stool with an iron frame and a 26 lb weight, but it sells as a single.

• Choose the Homy Casa if you want two stools in one order, a tall full back and a fabric seat for a dining nook or home bar.
• Choose the Armen Living Gardenia if you want arms, a built-in footrest and faux leather that wipes clean, and you only need one stool.