HP LaserJet Pro M234sdw vs Brother HL-L2405W Laser Printer

Buy the HP LaserJet Pro M234sdw if you need to copy and scan as well as print. It is a true all-in-one with a 40-sheet document feeder and automatic two-sided printing, so it handles contracts, forms and ID copies without a separate scanner. The Brother HL-L2405W is a print-only machine, but it is the better pure printer: a 250-sheet tray, dual-band Wi-Fi and a compact 14-inch footprint. Owners of both lines praise fast first pages and cheap high-yield toner; the HP's small 150-sheet tray and 1.6-inch icon LCD are the usual complaints, and the Brother's lack of scanning and duplex is its main limit.

• Choose the HP LaserJet Pro M234sdw if you need print, copy and scan in one box, want automatic two-sided printing, and can live with a 150-sheet tray.
• Choose the Brother HL-L2405W if you mostly print one-sided documents, want a bigger 250-sheet tray and a smaller footprint, and already have a way to scan.