HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One vs HP DeskJet 4255e All-in-One Printer

Buy the Smart Tank 5101 if you print a lot, especially in color, and want refillable tanks instead of cartridges. Buy the DeskJet 4255e if you mostly print occasional pages and want a 35-page automatic document feeder for scanning and copying stacks. The Smart Tank is the larger, heavier machine with higher running capacity; the DeskJet is compact and simpler. Owners rate the Smart Tank 4 out of 5 across about 1,300 ratings, and both are basic inkjets without duplex printing.

• Choose the HP Smart Tank 5101 if you print frequently, want refillable ink tanks with a large ink supply in the box, and can live without an automatic document feeder.
• Choose the HP DeskJet 4255e if you want a compact all-in-one with a 35-page automatic document feeder for scanning and copying multi-page documents.