HP Smart Tank 5101 vs Canon PIXMA G4270 MegaTank

Buy the HP Smart Tank 5101 for simple family printing of color documents and photos, with a spill-free refill system and self-healing Wi-Fi. Buy the Canon PIXMA G4270 if you need a document feeder, faxing or faster black-and-white output. The HP is lighter and easier to set up; the Canon is the better office machine. Owners of both tank lines praise the low running costs, but the HP's lack of an ADF and duplex is a real limit for multi-page scanning.

• Choose the HP Smart Tank 5101 if you mainly print color documents and photos at home and want the simplest refill and setup.
• Choose the Canon PIXMA G4270 if you scan multi-page documents, send faxes or print a lot of black-and-white text.