Which is better for printing photos?

The Envy 6152. It does borderless photo printing and automatic two-sided photos, and it has a color touchscreen. The Smart Tank 5102 prints photos too, but it is tuned for everyday documents.

Which costs less to run?

The Smart Tank 5102. Its refillable tanks and 2 years of ink in the box make it cheaper per page for regular printing. The Envy uses cartridges, which cost more over time.

Is the Smart Tank 5102 worth the extra $76.98?

Only if you print often. At $165.98 versus $89.00, the tank printer pays back through cheaper ink if you print several hundred pages a month. For light printing, the Envy is the better buy.

The Smart Tank 5102, at up to 12 ppm black versus up to 9 ppm mono on the Envy. The Smart Tank's color speed is slower, at up to 5 ppm.

Does either print double-sided automatically?

The Envy 6152 does, for both photos and documents. The Smart Tank 5102 only does manual duplex with driver support.

Which is better for a home office?

The Smart Tank 5102, because of its higher duty cycle, 100-sheet tray and lower ink cost. The Envy is better as a family and photo printer.

HP Smart Tank 5102 vs HP Envy 6152 All-in-One Printer

Buy the Envy 6152 if you print photos and want to spend less up front: it is $89.00 at Walmart as of November 6, 2026, versus $165.98 at eBay for the Smart Tank 5102. Buy the Smart Tank 5102 if you print a lot of documents and want refillable tanks instead of cartridges, plus a higher 3,000-page monthly duty cycle. The Envy is the better photo printer and the cheaper buy; the Smart Tank is the better long-run cost per page.

Today the HP Envy 6152 All-in-One Printer costs $76.98 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.