HP Smart Tank 6003 All-in-One Printer vs HP Envy 6155e All-in-One Printer

Buy the Smart Tank 6003 if you print a lot, especially in color, and want the lowest ongoing ink cost. Its refillable tanks and the ink included in the box make it the cheaper printer to run over years, and it prints faster at 12 ppm mono. The Envy 6155e is the smaller, lighter pick with a touchscreen, AirPrint and fax, and it suits light home use and families. Owners rate the Smart Tank well at 4.4 from 359 ratings; the Envy is a compact all-rounder but its cartridges cost more per page.

• Choose the HP Smart Tank 6003 if you print high volumes, want refillable tanks and automatic duplex, and care most about long-term running value.
• Choose the HP Envy 6155e if you want a compact, light printer with a touchscreen, AirPrint and fax for light family use.