Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker vs Newair Countertop Ice Maker

The Newair AI-215SS is the stronger pick for most households. It makes more ice per day, holds a bigger bin, offers three cube sizes and has a much larger review base at a higher rating. The Igloo is smaller, lighter and easier to move, so it suits tight counters, dorms and RV trips. Owners of both describe bullet ice that is soft and melts fast in drinks; neither is a freezer-grade machine.

• Choose the Igloo if you have little counter space, want a light machine you can carry to a patio or RV, and only need ice for a few drinks at a time.
• Choose the Newair if you host often, want more ice on hand and three cube sizes, and value a long track record of owner ratings.